Allure Homme Edition Blanche or Dior Homme Sport?

[Emospence]

One of these two will be my new office scent..

Which do you prefer, and why!

[Sylver]

Edition Blanche for casual wearing or even office (during summer), if we compare with DHS 2008 (which is a more sporty version than EB). If we compare EB with DHS 2012, my pick is again EB just because the 2012 version of Dior and my skin dont interact very well in terms of performance.

[hednic]

Dior Homme Sport

[Shiny Beast]

DHS by miles

[rhaybans]

don't care for either. would point you away from both.

[Fragmeister]

I own the Chanel and love it. I don't know the other.

[rbaker]

EB by a long shot - more unique lemon ice cream note.

[Emospence]

don't care for either. would point you away from both.

What would you point me towards, for discussions' sake?

[Ivan D' Great]

Edition Blanche

[PlayaYoungThugz]

Both are must haves.. But Blanche "Sport is even better" QUALITY!

[Zgb]

DHS definitely

[uhbhatti88]

DHS, simply more invigorating and the ginger twist helps set it apart. versatile to boot for day or evening.

EB isn't bad by any means, but to me feels like it has a more restricted use: as a cologne for the afternoon transition to evening.

[Johno]

Blanche by far.

DHS has a disgusting ginger note that ruins everything.

[dudelove]

DHS has a disgusting ginger note that ruins everything.

Try the 2012 reformulation then, the ginger is very toned down. Smoother and slightly sweeter as well. Love the hint of iris which give the reformulation class that isn't usually associated with "sports" fragrances. I wouldn't be afraid of wearing this with a shirt and tie.

[fragrance123]

Aren't they actually kinda 'similar' ?. Would it be an overlap if somebody has both ?.

[sjg3839]

Edition Blanche

[dougczar]

Own all 3, and even have backup bottles of all of them (EB, DHS 2008, DHS 2012).

I really can't pick a favorite - If I could only have 5 fragrances for the whole summer, I think EB and at least one of the DHS versions would be in that 5. So, it would be like picking my favorite child.

[Ken_Russell]

Dhs

[badarun]

Same issue --->>>

I own the Chanel and love it. I don't know the other.

[Jridgen]

I owned but sold DHS whereas EB is one my top work fragrances. I should note though I sold "vintage" DHS and have not tried the reform yet.

[mrcologneguy]

Edition Blanche. Haven't sniffed the new version of DHS - high hopes for it.

[senore01]

Dior Homme Sport for me. deeper, richer, longer lasting. I enjoy boy fragrances very much but DHS wins in my book.

[LJD]

Own all 3, and even have backup bottles of all of them (EB, DHS 2008, DHS 2012).

I really can't pick a favorite - If I could only have 5 fragrances for the whole summer, I think EB and at least one of the DHS versions would be in that 5. So, it would be like picking my favorite child.

Hello dougczar,
I don't know if you've ever tried DHS 2012 (the only one easily available for me) and AH ed. blanche side by side...
Do you concur longevity is better on DHS 2012 than on the AHeb ?
Unfortunately the Chanel is fleeting quickly on my skin...
Thanks !

- - - Updated - - -

Dior Homme Sport for me. deeper, richer, longer lasting. I enjoy boy fragrances very much but DHS wins in my book.

Hello senore01 !
Are you referring to DHS 2012 or the "old" one ?
Thanks !

[Kielecki]

Allure Homme Edition Blanche just better for me

[fit&frag'd]

The reformed DHS would be my pick.

[Emospence]

Aren't they actually kinda 'similar' ?. Would it be an overlap if somebody has both ?.

Which is why I wanna pick just one!

[VanAllan]

Allure Homme Edition Blanche

[Sol invictus]

Edition Blanche. Haven't sniffed the new version of DHS - high hopes for it.

I prefer the new DHS to the old one; The ginger has been toned down, and the little bit of iris smoothes the lemon, almost giving it a creamy aspect to it. I can see the comparisons to Edition Blanche in that respect.
However, I prefer EB to either versions of DHS.

[fraghead93]

Edition Blanche.

[silentrich]

If your looking for performance it's DHS hands down. Edition Blanche doesn't project or last that well. The problem I have with EB is that it has a great creamy lemon opening with a touch of pepper and once that goes away it's nothing but a cheap smelling tonka bean. DHS (2008) is a bit sharp up top with a ton of ginger and lemon, but it dries down with musk, woods, and retains the ginger. Can't comment on the 2012 version, but from the time that I tested it I liked the smell better, but the longevity and projection sucks.

Opening: Edition Blanche
Dry Down: DHS
Longevity: DHS
Projection: DHS
Versatility: DHS
Compliment factor: Probably a tie, but DHS will be more noticable.

[L'Homme Blanc Individuel]

One of these two will be my new office scent..

Which do you prefer, and why!

Which do YOU prefer? That's the only question that matters. Edition Blanche is too much of a lemon bomb for me. It smells like cleaning products.

[mikesc]

Both are great, but EB by a hair.

[voidvader]

Allure Homme Edition Blanche just better for me

i agree.

[Azieru]

EB is a far better work office fragrance.

[drseid]

Neither is particularly good, IMO, but I prefer DHS of the two.

[Freeze]

DHS is one of my favorite summer scents. Edition Blanche never really grabbed a hold of me.

[Tony T]

allure is a great warm weather scent that has longevity. i sold my dhs

[Emospence]

So, the DHS lasts longer and projects better then?

[trapper]

Allure Homme Edition Blanche is more complex and beautifully crafted.

[Stesa]

Both are easily sampled locally at Takashimaya and the like department stores. Personally prefer DHS but strongly suggest you make the effort to try before buying given that those 2 are available at silly money prices.

[fragrance123]

I like Chanel Edition Blanche better.

[ToughCool]

Which do YOU prefer? That's the only question that matters. Edition Blanche is too much of a lemon bomb for me. It smells like cleaning products.

This. DHS seems more well rounded and smooth. EBs overwhelming Creamy lemon dry down is obnoxious after about an hour. Just can't deal with it.

[telecaster]

Dhs

[nfn1983]

Dior Homme Sport for me...

[silvermountainhigh]

Dhs 2012.