Amouage Ceil Man or Reflection Man??? which should I buy and why?

[Foxxworthi]

Amouage Ceil Man or Reflection Man??? which should I buy and why?

I own epic man, Jubalation 25, Memoir man, Lyric man...

any suggestion or comparison

[JiveHippo]

Buy the one you like most because you will be happiest with it.

[heperd]

Ciel, because Reflection smells just like Le Male.

[hednic]

Buy the one you like most because you will be happiest with it.

Agree.

[The_Scentinel]

Ciel, because Reflection smells just like Le Male.

I respectfully disagree. I never got this association at all. Reflection is a fine scent IMO and the better choice of the two.

[TLS]

Ciel, because Reflection smells just like Le Male.

Sorry but this is not true.

[Rev320]

I own both and would pick Ciel over Reflection. But as always purchase the one you enjoy most.

If you're looking for a springtime Amouage give Silver a try or Opus III even.

[badarun]

What???????????????

Ciel, because Reflection smells just like Le Male.

Reflection is an amazing parfum - Le Male is amazing on longevity - that's as far as I can think of the similarity betn these 2!!!

[JDBIII]

Reflection is beautiful but confuses me. I find Ciel to be a more direct and cogent expression of a fragrance idea.

[OctaVariuM]

Although I've only smelled Ciel once, I think I'd still prefer Reflection. That being said, I think Ciel is probably easier to wear and still pretty interesting with the peach and woods combination.

[TLS]

Ciel is soapy.

[Kielecki]

Reflection doe not smell like le male!!!
Both are nice but reflection is more unique scent

- - - Updated - - -

Also checkout Interlude

[Shiny Beast]

Ciel, because Reflection smells just like Le Male.

- - - Updated - - -

I'd get samples of each and test drive them. Between the two, I'd choose Reflection.

[rhaybans]

both have been equally disappointing for me. sorry...

[Attila]

Reflection is like a refined version of Le Male. It does smell very similar. Especially the opening.
I am not a fan of Ciel Man but it is very suitable for summer.
Its your choice. I would choose Reflection man though.

[Nersh]

RM from me.

[heperd]

How in the world do all of you guys not smell the similarity between Le Male and Reflection?

[Shiny Beast]

How in the world do all of you guys not smell the similarity between Le Male and Reflection?

Le Male is all lavender and vanilla on me, Reflection has no lavender or vanilla. I'll say that they smell similar at the very top, like literally the first few seconds and then the rest is pretty different. That's my take.