Not surprised if it's a really solid perfume since Yann Vasnier is the perfumer. I like almost everything he does in fragrance. My sample is on its way. I have heard others say it is good too, but not all that different from other oud and rose fragrances. Look forward to trying it out. Did you try Tobacco Oud that came out with it? I've heard it is an "ouded up" Tobacco Vanille. I imagine that they've have time to contemplate the error of their ways and improve on TV by now - I look forward to that one too.