Let me throw out where the moderation is going on this. Remember the old Guerlain threads? Well, there aren't as many of them, because the Guerlain people spend most of their time on Facebook now (which is something of a hint). But those old Guerlain threads were very pleasant places, where people who cared about the brand could rave or moan, and call things brilliant or trash, and still remain friends, and loyal followers of the brand. I would love to see ALL brand-related threads like that. What we DO NOT want is for the dysfunction that too often visits Creed threads to spread. That is simply not acceptable. The old Guerlain threads had an element of courtesy which we really need to spread to all of Basenotes.