Welcome to Basenotes!
I think you're probably going to get answers all over the place on this one. It's pretty difficult to quantify "female attention," and my impression is that some people/women will prefer one, some will like both, and some will like neither. I know--that's not very helpful
Which one do YOU like best? Which one makes YOU feel the most comfortable and confident? In that case, wear the one that makes you feel more confident. My thought is that confidence will get more attention than a fragrance. Just my opinion.