Derby by a HUGE margin.
Thread: BDP vs Derby
Hello all, I'm new to the forum and seasons greetings. I've decided I'm going to treat myself to a new bottle. Having tried lots I've narrowed it down to the Creed and Guerlain heavyweights BDP and Derby. I notice that both receive much acclaim on here but when pitted against each other which do people prefer?
I own both (both new formulations)
I would go for BDP
Being the stronger and more lasting
The opening lavender of BdP is harsh but the woody drydown is very good. Though I will have to give the edge to Derby for it's wonderful complexity.
Another for Derby (& by a mile) in terms of the scent.
BdP however does have more longevity on me.
Tough choice, but I give the slight edge to Derby.
It sounds as if you have tried both; which do you prefer?
Derby is a fine fragrance, but I do have longevity issues with it (non-vintage formulation). BdP truly is one of my favourites and has no such longevity problems. If I had to choose only one, it would have to be BdP. I would miss the Derby though.
"No elegance is possible without it...perfume is a part of you." Gabrielle "Coco" Chanel
D E R B Y
and.....new york PdN over BdP
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Own and love both but prefer Derby
Remember that while it is perfectly acceptable to criticize the content of a post - criticizing the poster is not.
Mean spirited, nasty, snide, sarcastic, hateful, and rude individuals on Basenotes don't warrant or deserve other individuals' acknowledgement or respect.
That's tough. I find the longevity on both to be very good. Both smell great. I think if forced to pick I would go with BdP. Can't go wrong with either.
You should have made a poll for this.
Make that 9. Derby is much better.
MEMO: Italian Leather // Ermenegildo Zegna: Haitian Vetiver / Italian Bergamot
Roja Dove: Amber Aoud Crystal Parfum / Danger Pour Homme Parfum / Fetish Pour Homme Parfum /
Creation-E Pour Homme Parfum / Scandal Pour Homme EdP
Xerjoff: 1861 // Dunhill London: ICON
Hermess: Bel Ami / Bel Ami Vetiver // Bond No.9: NY Amber / NY Oud
Armani Privé: Myrrhe Imperiale / Oud Royal / Rose D'Arabie
Christian Dior La Collection Privée: Feve Delicieuse / Ambre Nuit / Oud Ispahan / Bois d'Argent / Leather Oud
Creed: Windsor / Royal Oud / Green Irish Tweed / Jardin d'Amalfi / Pure White Cologne
Puredistance: M / Black // House of Matriarch: Blackbird / SexMagic
Mancera // Acqua di Parma // Atelier Cologne // Huitième Art
Amouage // Profumum Roma // Jovoy Paris // Lubin // D.S. & Durga