I own both Joop! Homme (vintage version) and Bogart pour homme. Bogart is definitely one of my favs!
Sweet cherry pipe tobacco with lots of tonka bean and some vanilla. To me the cherry is not that noticable and the sweetness is just right! Utterly masculine fragrance as well! Joop! Homme is very sweet and loud and has therefor to be applied very carefully when you want it 'to work' in the drydown!
Bogart is pretty loud first 1-2 hrs (depending on amount of application) but then settles nicely and has average projection for 6 more hrs or so before becoming a skin scent. Bogart would be a no brainer for me out of these two! It is also very cheap so you can't 'go wrong'.
(I also own Amen vintage and that one eats both of these fragrances regarding longevity and sillage!)