Much of a muchness I think. On me I recall ES having better longevity, though very close to the skin after 3-4 hours whereas PM just disappears completely. PM is nicer though.
Have you considered PM concentree? It is certainly not identical but IMO is not as different as many consider it to be and it has very good longevity.
Others to consider could be Penhaligon's Blenheim Bouquet (though there is a prominent pine note also) or Acqua di Parma Colonia Intensa. I believe the Guerlain EdCs are also good, but not tried them personally.