No. No offense to any, but many reviews are a case of the emperor's new clothes.
Do you ever find that you really like a fragrance but have doubts about it strictly because the fragrance has negative reviews and comments, both here on basenotes and elsewhere? I'm not talking about general differences of opinion but instances in which a fragrance has overwhelmingly negative responses. For instance, I received samples of a fragrance that has received one of the worst drubbings of any fragrance released in the last couple of years, but each time I wore the samples, I found that I really liked it more and more. I know that we are inclined to say "wear what you like," but I found that I couldn't stop second-guessing myself and wondering what was wrong with me for liking a fragrance that almost everyone seemed to say was bad, which kept me from buying it.
Has that ever happened to you?
No. No offense to any, but many reviews are a case of the emperor's new clothes.
I have a confession that many years ago I had a bottle of Joop that I wore everyday for eighteen months. I enjoyed it at the time and I never had any negative feedback.
Since coming onto basenotes years later I see the negative reviews and comments and look back and wonder why I liked it. And also wonder why no one said anything bad about it at work. But it's all in retrospect as I have since moved on in my taste.
Well I never let it keep me from buying it, but my buddy Serge Noire got knocked around pretty good in the reviews if memory serves correct. Since the only nose that knows best is the one on one's face, I bought it without a second thought and have no regrets.
Also, with all the IFRA restrictions, reformulations, and aging & handling variables... who really knows if what you're smelling and what 'they' were smelling are the same (enough). Plus, I really don't care a hoot if a bunch of 20 somethings, or such, think that Azzaro pH or Kouros or <you get the picture> are vile concoctions, then go on about positive qualities of 1 million or some other sweet current offering. Hell, I'm in my 50s and a bit of an old-schooler; I wouldn't expect to share a lot of common tastes. Perspective is everything.
I said it once and I'll say it again: to me, reviews are more a reflection of the reviewer's tastes than an accurate reflection of what's actually inside that bottle of cologne and whether it'll appeal to you.
Last edited by DuNezDeBuzier; 19th February 2014 at 11:42 PM.
Wanna Shop? --> Buzier's Sales
MY TOP 25%: Al Oudh, Azzaro pH, Basala, Bel Ami, Black Afgano, Blackbird, Blend 30, Bull's Blood, Chaps Original, Cuba, DK Men - Fuel, Davidoff '84, Derby, Edition, Elsha 1776, Equipage, Eau d' Hermes, Egoiste Cologne Concentree, Fetish pH, Fougere Royal reissue, Genghis Khan, Green Water, Havana, Jules, Kiehl's Musk, Knize Ten, Kouros, L'Homme Sage, Leather Oud, Loewe pH, Monogram, Montecristo, Musc Ravageur, Olibanum, Perry Ellis for Men Original, Piper Nigrum, Polo, Puredistance M, Santal Noble, Santalum, Sandalo (Villoresi), Tea for Two, Tribute Attar, Ungaro II, Versace l'homme, Yatagan, YSL pH
No, I don't really care what others think. I enjoy Armani Code Sport, people here hate it. When it's discontinued in 5 years, I'm sure it'll be a big hit here :-)
Brineapple (Pineapple, Guava, Ylang Ylang, Marine Notes, Green Tea, Cade, Guaiacwood, Cedar Wood, Ozone) / Fur - (Vintage Musks, Woods, Leather) / Onsen Wood (Hinoki/Hiba/Cedar/Yuzu) / Winter XVI (Tree Saps, Extractions and Resins, Bois des Landes, Bourbon Vetiver, Spearmint, Frankincense & Myrrh) / L.O.M. Leather Oud Musk (Leather, Oud, Musk, Beeswax, Tobacco, Strawberry, Incense & Amber)
Not really. I still love my Kenneth Cole fragrances that I own - and they sure aren't Basenotes darlings.
Also, I don't second guess my dislike of many fragrances that are wildly adored by many people here.
Besides, I have realized that Basenotes consensus is quite a moving target. Just look at Tobacco Vanille - 2 years ago, it was the greatest thing ever created. Now, seems more people are jumping all over it "cloying", "vanilla candle", etc...
Just sniff it and decide for yourself -- always good to be a trend setter anyway.
Not in the slightest. You have got be a very insecure person who is unsure of what your own personal tastes, likes/dislikes are and/or easily influenced by others if your concerned about not wearing something you really like the smell of because strangers on the internet tell you they dont like it, or its inferior, or any other reason for that matter... lol.
Escentric Molecule 01 comes to mind... alot of negative chatter (about not being able to smell it, whole lot of nothing, I could mix a batch of ISO E Super in my basement for 1/10 of the price...etc). Happen to like this one especially on warmer days. Get a cedar note that's addicting.
An investment in knowledge pays the best interest
- Benjamin Franklin
Not really. I like what I like. I do take others' viewpoints into consideration, especially when it comes to specific notes in a fragrance but each nose is different and I trust my nose most of all. If someone I spend a lot of time with doesn't like it (i.e. My girlfriend), I try not to wear it around that individual. What I'm trying to say is, others' input helps but you like what you like. If you start noticing people around you are covering their noses or giving you negative feedback then you might want to consider wearing something else but I wouldn't worry too much.
Never. While I respect and appreciate what people have to say positively or negatively about any fragrance, it never has any influence on whether I purchase the fragrance or not.
Remember that while it is perfectly acceptable to criticize the content of a post - criticizing the poster is not.
Mean spirited, nasty, snide, sarcastic, hateful, and rude individuals on Basenotes don't warrant or deserve my or other Basenoters' acknowledgement or respect.
Nah, most of the scents I own are cheap designers that wouldn't get much love from most and especially not here. But I rock them proudly anyway because they smell great to me!(Ed Hardy Born Wild is one of my signature scents for example ) Now am I always proud to admit the name of the fragrance I'm wearing when it gets complimented or asked what it is?! Well....that's a different question all together!lol
No, but sometimes my own opinion of a fragrance changes and things that I come to dislike about it may be things that I had previously read in a review but had failed to see, smell, or understand.
But don't let the reviews make you doubt yourself!
Last edited by Buysblind; 20th February 2014 at 01:32 AM.
Yes a lot of people on the internet with "refined noses" hate on YSL L'Homme Parfum Intense but I love it and so do everyone I show it to and women at work. A lot of people hate on flankers and give them horrible reviews because they "are too different from the original" Half of my top 6 are flankers so I'm not to worried. Also I love Fahrenheit 32 but a lot of people hate on it lol.
No. I'm interested in reading people's analysis of a scent, and even reasons why they don't like it, but it has never swayed my opinion about a fragrance I already like. I cannot, however, rule out Basenotes raves and hype surrounding popular scents from instilling expectation bias and perhaps making me like something more than I would have if I'd sampled it without reading a thing about it. Still, understanding a scent can often help me appreciate and like it more.
Very negative reviews at Basenotes are pretty often written by the
"If it's not a work of art I dislike it"/ " If I detect anything synthetic I hate it"/ "If it's not a feminine scent, it's not bottle worthy"/ "I only wear fragrance for my own personal pleasure"/ "If it's not niche it's not good"/ "It's crap" types.
I only really pay attention to the negative reviews of the
"It doesn't last long enough and I feel ripped off"/ "It's too darn girlie, how can any man wear this stuff?" types.
Last edited by Renato; 20th February 2014 at 01:58 AM.
Reading reviews influences you, whether you like it or not. If you read a review just before sampling a fragrance, you will be focussed if you experience the same thing as told in the review. If the review says projection is poor... you are going to test it... and maybe agree to it. If the review says something smells like piss (yes there was a review saying that about Kouros) you will be smelling and wondering if you smell it as well! Chances are you will smell it, while you wouldn't have smelled it if you didn't read about it. So yes, you are always being influenced.
Can you be influenced afterwards? I think you can. If a lot of people (or reviews) would tell you, your favourite fragrance stinks, you might ending up not wearing it anymore, since you associate the criticism with the fragrance. "If so many people say it stinks.... it can't be any good." If you only read one or two negative reviews I wouldn't bother. Situation would change though if people close to you would start complaining. Then it becomes personal. Probably you don't want to be that stinky guy, and chances are your favourite fragrance won't be your friend anymore
Last edited by TheSnifferMan; 20th February 2014 at 01:59 AM.
I like and often wear Gucci by Gucci Pour Homme, so that I think that's a no from me.
I wear scents that are pleasant to me and have utilitarian value and hopefully last.
I couldn't care less how exclusive or artistic a scent is. I wear it all day for the above reasons. Id wear old spice pure sport body wash if they made it a fragrance.
I think too many of us get caught up in only wearing scents that only other scent heads deem as having artistic merit, and its silly.
This seems about right.
Sure, negative comments influences me. Sure, I second guess myself.
But I still like it, and I will still wear it.
I've had the opposite experience. I didn't like a scent, read positive reviews, revisited the scent, and decided I liked it. Sometimes reviewers point out notes or qualities I missed. Being influenced by others isn't necessarily a bad thing.
First thing i do if i'm interested in a fragrance is :
- Find out what are the dominant notes in its composition based on votes ( an awesome feature on another site which i really like).
- Check out the longevity/projection votes ( on another site)
Negative reviews don't really play any role before i buy because tastes are subjective.
Hypocrites will always be a thorn in my back....and my middle finger will always be the best remedy.....
Random slating of a perfume I like won't make me dislike it, but reviews that point out an aspect or an association that I hadn't noticed have ruined a couple of perfumes. As soon as someone mentioned that Bois Farine smelled like peanut butter, I knew I'd never wear it again.
And on the flip side, I like to see perfumes that I like rated highly by people whose opinions I respect. Some opinions and reviews have more weight than others, however.
Maybe at first, but after a while you get to know your fellow members. Member x may hate a certain house, so when you hear member x talk about or review a fragrance from that house, you know this individuals opinion you have to ignore.
only influence: the reviews about a scent lacking sillage/duration
It sometimes helps to get a general feel of a fragrance. That's about it. If I like the fragrance, it's good to go.
"Your" nose knows best.
Last edited by thebeck; 20th February 2014 at 01:36 PM.