I am not throwing false claims around, I was speaking of your tune and how you addressed many replies in this thread. And I explained why, even though you did not say those things directly, that meaning could be inferred from your attitude. Now I do not remember what fate woman smells like, and even if it was fantastic, 1 out of 8 releases after memoir. But congratulations on showing me that retailers exploit the fame of some people to sell a product? Where did I claim that there are no people who value Turin's opinion? It is simply not mine, and not that of many here. And he is indeed a biased, not so great, reviewer as I mentioned before. I could give you examples from his book that show "bad reviewing" and why I don't hold his opinion that highly, but you are probably more familiar with it than I am anyway. My point simply was that you had no basis to quote him like his reviews are some universal truth; you did not know whether we care or not about his opinion.
Listen, I have not been around these boards for a long time and have had no interests into going through such arguments. But if you have not noticed how you discouraged everybody who is not a fan of amouage later releases, and also Luca Turin, from participating in your thread. Sure none of us has mentioned elaborately why we think those releases are inferior. But you left no space for such discussion because you immediately went off with the presumption that we are wrong for thinking so because Turin and Chong have more "expertise" than us so our "opinion" is worthless. Now you can go on with your condescending better-than-thou attitude, I am done with you and your thread.