I would consider 125 Years Your Companion For Life by Victorinox Swiss Army for men. This is an obscure cheapy. More similar to LIDG, not LIDGE, because of the citrus. I own both this and LIDG, and they both smell similar, of course LIDG is heavier, better quality, that's expected from Guerlain. but 125 Years definitely does not smell cheap. It's like a thinner cocoa, not patchouli (which I actually like), more citrus, and tonka. Very safe fragrance, and at its price point, you can't really complain.