Quote Originally Posted by remik View Post
Yes they are different, but if you take the rose from Potion Black and amplify it 100 times, you'll get somewhat close to Oud Ispahan. At regular concentration, they are different enough.
The Rose in BP, is smothered in tobacco, the rose is more of a synthetic rose, while the rose in OI, has a very natural syrupy rose . I guess everyone has different noses, It would be interesting to see what other members who have both or have tried these fragrances have to say.