Well since most of the "ultimate compliment getters" are widely known mainstream fragrances....and you state you don't like wearing those. You might not be getting "ultimate" ones....but still many very good ones!
original Curve(all time top compliment getter)
Allure Home Sport and Versace PH are tops too....but again, probably not something your interested in
So....a couple of VERY good(somewhat out of the norm)compliment getters as of late
Bond #9 Scent Of Peace
BOTH Lacoste L-12 White and L-12 Noir(which I might argue gets even more comments than White)
Mont Blanc Legend Intense