strange question

[pobepto]

Hello
I have a strange question about the amount of ethyl vanillin given an amount of vanillin.
For example: i have a formula with 10 per cent vanillin, what amount of ethyl vanillin should i add to have the same power? I know that the smell is a bit different, but i don t have vanillin...
I read that ethyl vanillin is 10x more powerful than vanillin, so the ratio would be 1/10? Or what?
Thank you all
Robert

[Kurn]

What's holding you back trying?

[pobepto]

The big waste of matetials...

[pkiler]

The big waste of matetials...

Since both materials are dirt cheap, and powdered, your experiments would be both diluted and inexpensive.

[mattmeleg]

Hello
I have a strange question about the amount of ethyl vanillin given an amount of vanillin.
For example: i have a formula with 10 per cent vanillin, what amount of ethyl vanillin should i add to have the same power? I know that the smell is a bit different, but i don t have vanillin...
I read that ethyl vanillin is 10x more powerful than vanillin, so the ratio would be 1/10? Or what?
Thank you all
Robert

Robert,
For me, for some reason I have a harder time smelling ethyl vanillin than I do vanillin...
I think you really do have to make up equal amounts of both, compare on test strips...