These are things of which I have bottles (partial or full), mini bottles, roll-ons, or 1 oz decants.
May have to start a longevity one too...
Rating System: (Borrowed from another basenotes user and modified for myself)
5 Stars - "I love it!" Just love it, would wear all the time. The whole thing (top to base) is good.
4 Stars - "I like it." It's good, may have a minor problem or two (e.g. takes a couple minutes to really start smelling nice, or fades too fast, but not enough to bother me)
3 Stars - "It's okay." Might use up a sample or small decant, but I don't like it enough to get more. Not fantastic, not horrible. Probably wouldn't want a bottle. Probably has issues with one level or another (e.g. drydown isn't as good as the opening, or vice versa, the good part doesn't outweigh the bad), or has one problem note. Why put up with it when there are other things to try? (Escadas are in this category for me; just a little too sharp or musky or something--too generic?)
2 Stars - "I don't like it." I wouldn't wear it. I don't like it much, and don't want a bottle. May have a good point or two, but definitely not enough to keep any of it on hand.
1 Star - "I hate it!" Makes me wrinkle my nose with disgust.