Making a list and checking it... Twice?

[Old Factory]

So I started out thinking I'll make a list of all the fragrances I liked and loved. Figured it made most sense because it would likely be smaller than those I don't and easier to maintain because of it. However, now I'm wondering if it wouldn't have been best to make a second list of those I hated also. I mean, there's far more of them, so it's hard to remember exactly if I have tried something, especially since I recognize the name of it, whether from ads, samples, or just seeing them discussed here.

In fact, there's so many that I truly detest that is astounding. And even more that I've tried and found utterly lacking, especially compared to others, and determined as unworthy because of this.

Just a thought. Really wish I had listed them all with thumbs up or down next to each.

[Bonnette]

No time like the present to start keeping two lists, then!

[sjg3839]

Sounds good.

[Rüssel]

Can be done on Fragrantica and perhaps even on this site via the star rating.

[purecaramel]

So I started out thinking I'll make a list of all the fragrances I liked and loved. Figured it made most sense because it would likely be smaller than those I don't and easier to maintain because of it. However, now I'm wondering if it wouldn't have been best to make a second list of those I hated also. I mean, there's far more of them, so it's hard to remember exactly if I have tried something, especially since I recognize the name of it, whether from ads, samples, or just seeing them discussed here.

In fact, there's so many that I truly detest that is astounding. And even more that I've tried and found utterly lacking, especially compared to others, and determined as unworthy because of this.

Just a thought. Really wish I had listed them all with thumbs up or down next to each.

I have found listing my "Tried" and "Own" in Wardrobe has brought some measure "Knowing Thyself" "Truth"

[Danny Mitchell]

The interesting part could be how these lists evolve and change several months or a year from now. A lot of things I hate initially, I come around on them and love them. POLO being a prime example.

[hednic]

Two lists sound fine